Test
Instruments
For
The
Hobbyist
Subjects:
1. RigExpert Antenna Analyzers
Updated 08/22/21
2. LoadStar SG-4160B
3. MFJ-259, AW07A, Analyzers, Other
Antenna Analyzers
4. Spectrum/Network
Analyzers
5. Juntek Signal Generator
6. MFJ-894 SWR/Wattmeter
Calibration
1. RigExpert Analyzers
I recently acquired a new RigExpert AA-650 antenna
analyzer - here's my unbiased assessment of the analyzer.
First, it's important to make it clear that the
RigExpert antenna analyzer is a top teir device in terms of cost, if you choose
to purchase one you soon realize some sticker shock, the one I purchased was the
AA-650 model (100Hz - 650 Mhz), the cost depending from whom you purchase it is
approximately $700.00 + S&H. So, for the most part, it's intended for the
serious technician in a lab testing environment, or an experienced ham that
can afford the expense.
If you fit into one of the above categories I
highly recommend the antenna analyzer. The analyzer is a precision quality
device, I rate it at five stars.
I won't discuss all the features of the analyzer
here, suffice to say, it will perform all the comprehensive automated tests you
will ever need to perform with the push of a few keystrokes.
I performed extensive testing of the RigExpert
AA-650 against other testing instruments, it was precise and dead on including
testing it against results from a spectrum analyzer equipped with special VSWR
bridge.
RigExpert analyzers incorporate a
calibration mode and will run several self tests, however, it does not come with
calibration standards (open, short, load), you can purchase these, or make them
yourself, it's best to purchase quality calibration standards unless your a
skilled applications/lab engineer and can make them youself, you should
have a set in your instrument tool box. The analyzer comes
calibrated. If you purchase a commerical
set from a state side source they will cost you typically $200 - $400 for
a set.
Here are the specification details and link to the
RigExpert website:
https://rigexpert.com/
Specifications
Frequency range: 0.1 to 650 MHz.
Frequency entry: 1 kHz resolution.
Measurement for 25, 50, 75, 100, 150, 200, 300, 450 and 600-Ohms
systems.
SWR measurement range: 1 to 100 in numerical modes, 1 to 10 in chart modes.
R and X range:
0…2000, -2000…2000.
Display modes: SWR, return loss, R, X, Z, L, C, Magnitude, and Phase Angle at a
single frequency, SWR chart (100 points). SWR chart at fixed HAM bands by IARU
Regions (100 points), Cable tools (Velocity factor & Cable length measurer,
Stub tuner, Cable loss chart, Cable impedance chart), & TDR.
Optional open-short-load calibration in SWR, R, X,
or Smith/polar chart graph modes.
RF output:
– Connector type: N.
– Output signal shape: square, 0.1 to 200 MHz. For
higher frequencies, harmonics of the main signal are used.
– Output power: -10 dBm (at 50 Ohm
load).
Power:
– Three 1.2V, 1800…3000 mAh, Ni-MH batteries,
type AA.
– Max. 3 hours of continuous measurement, max. 2
days in standby mode when fully charged batteries are used.
– When the analyzer is connected to a PC or a DC
adapter with a USB socket, it takes power from these sources.
Interface:
– 320×240 color TFT display.
– 6×3 keys on the water-proof
keypad.
– Multilingual menus and help screens (English
– Spanish – Japanese).
– USB connection to a personal
computer.
– Bluetooth v. 4.2 (Single-mode, Class
B).
Accessories inside the box: Soft case, battery charger, rechargeable batteries, USB cable, N
to UHF adapter.
Dimensions:
23x10x5.5 cm (9x4x2”).
Operating temperature: 0…40 °C (32…104 °F).
Weight: 650g
(23 Oz).
Warranty: 2
years RigExpert Care.
GTIN-13:
4820185420297
RigExpert AA-650 ZOOM is made in
Ukraine.
I highly recommend RigExpert antenna analyzers,
the RigExpert antenna analyzer is well worth the investment. There's just
one recommendation I feel that's worth noting, substitute AA alkaline batteries
and modify the power cord for use in the USA. My explanation for this
follows:
If you choose to use the quick charger and VARTA
rechargeable batteries shipped with the analyzer, the device will consume a
fully charged set of batteries quickly. The anslyzer is shipped the VARTA 2700
mHa batteries and charger.
VARTA rechargeable batteries do not enjoy a stellar
reputation as a quality and dependable battery product (see reviews that
follow). Like many companies VARTA batteries are manufactured in China,
that in and of itself is not necessarily a bad thing, what's important is the
quality control procedures in the facility where they are
manufactured.
I had to fall back to using standard AA alkaline
batteries, which resolved the battery drain issue. After installing a new set of
AA alkaline batteries and using the analyzer throughout the week, the analyzer
battery charge indicator still showed a full charge, unlike the VATRA
rechargeable batteries that indicated a substantial loss of charge after only 10
minutes of use. Keep in mind that the AA rechargeable battery is starting off
with a lower voltage of 1.2V, while the 1.5 alkaline battery starts with a
voltage of 1.5 volts. YES, I did try another set of VARTA batteries, the result
was always the same, quick loss of charge after minimal use.
There may be other brands of rechargeable batteries
that perform better, but personally, I'm staying with AA alkaline batteries,
they work.
The charger is shipped with a European power cord
and adapter for use in the USA, the adapter is poor quality and is not
dependable in my opinion, I chose to cutoff the European two wire power
plug on the charger power cord and discarded both the adapter and power plug, I
installed a standard USA type two wire power plug. NO, I didn't install a 3-wire
power plug, the charger is all plastic construction and there's no chassis
ground.
Other than this one negative, I
highly recommend the RigExpert antenna analyzer as well worth the
investment, just substitute alkaline AA batteries and modify the power cord for
use in the USA.
Caution -
DO NOT PURCHASE VARTA RECHARGABLE BATTERIES.
Here Are Several
Consumer Reviews
Apr
26, 2021
Never buy them
Bought 20 VARTA AA of them, all turned bad after maybe 5 charges. My last
VARTA, forever.
Oct 28,
2020
What cheap pieces of Crap
these…
What cheap pieces of Crap these batteries are. Do not buy because
you will be extremely disappointed.
Sep
27, 2020
Don't buy varta batteries
absolute…
Don't buy varta batteries absolute rubbish!! Bought a whole packet they
weren't man enough for my hive clock to work and there isn't much power in a
hive clock.
Updated Jun 14, 2020
Dreadful,
useless batteries
Dreadful, useless batteries. Sold in big packs at Bunnings, they
seem excellent value - but be warned, THEY ARE NOT! I have used their AA
alkaline gold-top batteries twice in a digital camera. Each time they ran out of
juice after 15 or so photos. Unbelievable! This is a camera that happily ran on
bog-standard Coles alkaline batteries for perhaps 50 or 60 photos.
AVOID!
Jun 12, 2020
Made in China
Varta website says: 'Varta means Made in Germany'. So I ordered a charger and 4 packets of rechargeable
batteries. When I unpacked them every single item was marked MADE IN CHINA. I
emailed them about their dishonest website but they have not replied. Won't be
buying Varta again.
Jan 2,
2020
These are the worst batteries I've
ever…
These
are the worst batteries I've ever bought. Put a new one in our wall clock (which
it says they can run on the packaging) and it couldn't run it after only a few
hours. Tried a different one from the pack and the same thing.
Aug
18, 2019
Waste of money and better exists out
there.
Not very great, I had two AA batteries in a digital clock. They were in
about three weeks and needed replacing. I bought the
batteries from my local B&Q, they were brand new. I went
back to B&Q after the batteries stopped working, to try and resolve
this.
I
managed to get a refund for the batteries, as I had the packaging and the
receipt. I'm very glad I did not throw those away, as I came very close to doing
so at one moment.
A
battery or more made by this company of beginners is like a pack of cards I
guess and maybe now and again they'd make a full packet of quality batteries.
I must however, say that 9/10 of their stock is faulty, bad quality
and likely to fail. On top of that, they are not cheap for what
they are either!
Set aside your money
and buy something a bit more reliable, who knows, it could save you a trip back
to the place you purchased them. Only to get back your money with no power to
the gadget you bought your batteries
for!
2. LoadStar SG-4160B Signal
Generator
Highly Recommended For The Hobbyist And Radio
Restoration.
I writing this review for any hobbyist that may be
looking for a great reasonably priced signal generator to fit the the beginners
pocketbook, as well as those that restore vintage radios that need to be
aligned. I own a LoadStar SG-4160B signal generator, I was extremly
surprised that the device was extremely frequency stable, you do need a bit
of a delicate touch when setting the last digit or two, but you'll get used to
it and develop a feel for adjusting the frequency, just a little patience and
you'll develop the skill. The price for these signal generators ranges between
$150.00 - $180.
Recommended
Modification
I made a digital readout modification to my SG4160B
signal generator, I added an inexpensive frequency counter to the SG4160B
generator, the modification is simple and quick, all that's required is a 200V
or higher .01uF decoupling capacitor, a BNC connector, and a small length of
miniature shielded coax, about .50 cents or less in total, drilling one
hole in the back of the cabinet, a little patience and about 1/2 - 1 hour in
time.
If you look around eBay you can generally find used
inexpensive frequency counters, or at an amateur radio hamfest. I purchased a
used DMI DigiMax D-500 frequency counter and interfaced it with the my
SG-4160B, it made a perfect addition to my SG-4160B for aligning
vintage radios and amateur radio gear.
I'm including a link to a great YouTube video that
specifically addresss not only how to use the SG-4160B for vintage radio
restoration alignment, it also shows in detail how to make the digital readout
modification to the SG-4160B. It provides two options with regard to the
modifying the SG-4160B, I chose the simplest of the two, which one you choose
depends on which frequency counter modification you opt to interface with the
SG-4160B.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Mgg8wvyDHw
3. MFJ
259, AW07A,& Other Antenna
Analyzers
This article has to do with MFJ, the AW07A, and other antenna analyzers
exhibiting frequency drift, it does not apply to newer graphical antenna
analyzers.
These older generation antenna analyzers are subject to a fair amount of
frequency drift when powered with internal double (AA) batteries. In a word,
they eat batteries like my dog eats puppy treats.
As the batteries degrade these analyzers cause increased frequency drifting. When the voltage of
the internal batteries of the MFJ-259 series, or the AW07A drop below 12 volts,
stability becomes more noticeable, and at 10 volts, forget it, frequency drift
is like watching a drunken sailor walking down a peer.
I’m not suggesting that these antenna analyzers are junk, or useless
instruments, what I’m suggesting is that you need to use an alternate power
source which can keep the voltage constant at 12V DC. This can be accomplished
with batteries with sufficient current handling capacity keeping the voltage
constant for an extended period of time, a regulated 12V DC (12VDC - 12.5VDC)
power adapter that plugs into an 115V - 120V AC outlet, or a 12V power supply
cord that plugs into your vehicles cigarette lighter. The car battery in your
vehicle will keep the voltage constant. Personally, I wouldn’t trust the results
of what the antenna analyzer is telling you if you power the device with eight
(8) 1.5V batteries. Above all, MAKE SURE THE POWER SOURCE IS REGULATED AND
FUSED.
The antenna analyzer will still exhibit some drift, they all do, however,
it will perform exceedingly better from these alternate power supply sources and
be more accurate.
If the antenna is located at a remote site, like a repeater site,
generally a 110 - 120 volt source will be available, or a back up battery(s) for
the repeater(s), if neither of these sources are available, then you’ll have to
transport a gel cell, tractor, or motorcycle battery along with the other
instruments and tools to the site to work on the antenna ........ there’s always
a way.
There are high tech antenna analyzers which are much more stable,
however, they can cost you $600 to over $1,000 that cover the HF/VHF/UHF, all
the way up to 2000MHz.
4. Spectrum/Network Analyzers
Right from the start the average ham can't afford the cost to purhase
spectrum/networks analyzers. Even a few years ago these instruments were out of
reach for most hobbyists and hams, not so many years ago I remember back in
the 70's and early 80's one could expect to layout up to $35,000 for one,
however the cost has decreased significantly due to advances in technology
making them much more afforable. Actually, prices have reached astronomical
lows.
So what is "afforable?" Truth be told, some well repected instrument
manufacturers now offer quality entry level spectrum analyzers for around
$1,000, not $75 - $100 toys on advertised on eBay, which are well
suited for the hobbyist and amateur radio enthusiast. YES, $1,000 is still
a sizable piece of change, but considerably less than what it used to be.
Chances are those transceivers you chat on most every day cost near as much for
a single all band rig.
Companies like Rigol offer decent reasonably priced analyzers well
equipped, one of the most popular is the Rigol DSA815-TG, the TG means that it
includes a tracking generator, typical cost is around $1200. Why is a tracking
generator important, well for one thing if your into repeaters and want to
tune up a duplexer for a repeater, you'll need a spectum analyzer with a
tracking generator. I won't elaborate on all the things you can accomplish with
a spectrum analyzer, you can visit a manufacturer's website to review the
specifications of various models and prices.
I have to be honest, I'm biased and believe that the Rigol
instruments are a step above most, in my opinion the Rigol DSA815-TG bechtop
analyzer is the best of affordable analyzers for the hobbyist and skilled
amateur radio operator, it's an outstanding analyzer with lots of bang for
the buck, featured packed and includes a 3 year warranty. My test bench is
comprised of numerous test instruments and all bare the Rigol brand name. YES,
I'm prediduced, but I base that consenus on my personal
experience. Everyone has to make their own choice and do their own research
before purchasing.
It's important to understand that if you haven't a lot of electronics
experience you're going to experience a large learning curve before you know how
to use sophisticated bench instruments, perhaps a technical colleage may be
a good place to start to learn electronics, if you're good at self
learning you can learn on your own and at your own pace, or perhaps a
friend you know whose highly skilled in electronics get started in the
right direction.
The bottom line, if you have interest in working on and repairing
electronics a spectrum analyzer is a great tool for your radio shack test
bench.
5. Juntek Programmable Signal
Generator.
The Juntek PSG9080 Signal Generator is decent reasonably
priced signal/arbitrary signal/waveform generator, selling for an
average of $198.00 to $230.00. For those on a limited budget, this is an
excellent choice.
The PSG9080 in my opinion is the best of the bunch in the lower priced
signal generators, unless you choose to step of to a Rigol, Rohde
Schwarz, Keysight, Tektronics, and etc., they're
considerably more expensive costing 3 to 4 times as much. Truth be told,
you can get a lot of bang for the buck for a lot less money if you choose a
Juntek PSG9080, and it's featured packed, and a great signal generator.
Especially for the ham who needs an test instrument for the budget minded ham's
test bench.
The down side is that generally you'll have to order it on line on
places like eBay and Amazon, they're shiiped out of China, and shipping can take
approximately 2 -3 weeks for delivery. I think it's worth the wait and
savings.
The second thing you need to do is make a 10 - 30 minute
modification. Most electronic test instruments produced and coming out of China
are not earth gounded, they are equipped with a USA style 3-wire electrical
plug, but it's not really properly earth grounded. There's information on
YouTube that will explain how to perform the simple modification, or you can
contact me and I help you with how to perform the mod.
Outside of this, the Juntek is an excellent signal generator, and
YES, it will produce sufficient modulation/signal for aligning radios up to
80 MHz (HF). It's capable of both internal and external signal source, it will
produce AM, FM, PM, ASK, FSK, & PSK modulation. It has a great easy to
read color display, great keyboard, dual; channel, RS232 interface, and many
more features. Don't let RS232 scare you, there are RS232 to USB cables
available on eBay, Amazon, and you might even find one at Walmart. It also comes
with software for your Windows PC.
The unit is well constructed with quality PCB boards and
components, I was surprised after examining the quality and it's light weight.
YUP, comes with a decent user manual.
I would like to see Juntek come out with a version covering up to 1
MHz to 470 MHz, (HF, VHF, UHF).
6. MFJ-894 SWR/Wattmeter
Calibration
MFJ–894
MFJ-894 cross needle SWR/Watt
meters are notoriously out of calibration from the factory, you can’t trust
them. Overall they are electrically and mechanically a decent meter, however,
they require alignment before relying on them for reasonable accurate readings.
To calibrate the meter use a known good transceiver with know output levels and
adjust the trimmers noted below, or a factory standard.
Top
Row VHF Reflected - Left To Right
200W
20W
2W
Bottom Row HF
Reflected - Left To Right
200W
20W
2W
Forward
Power Adjustment - Top To Bottom
Bob Krueger,
AB7CQ
Web
Administrator
RPTR 1:
146.920/146.320 PL 123.0 (WIRES-X Room 28187)
RPTR 2:
444.600 / 449.600 PL 100 (LAN Linked)
Simplex IRLP
Node: 7515 PL114.8 (146.540)
Email: ab7cqradio@ebidpal.com
You are here: Home-Test Instruments
Previous Topic: Tube Testers Next Topic: Digital Radio
|